Skip to main content

What's in a Meme?: Meme History, Highlights, and Hate Speech.

Everybody loves memes. Even those who claim indifference probably unknowingly quote a meme every once in a while. Memes can bring people together or tear them apart, and their power as cultural objects is an under-studied phenomenon. In my blog, I will explore memes in marketing and reach a conclusion on how best to approach them professionally. However, before exploring memes in the context of communications, we must explore both their history as well as their role in present day internet culture.

(Meme made by me depicting my current feelings)

Origin of the Word "Meme"

    In 1976, zoologist and science communicator Richard Dawkins coined the word “meme” in his book “The Selfish Gene.” As Sarah Huddle describes in “The Birth of a Meme - What is it Anyway?,” Dawkins was interested in the way that cultural ideas replicate and spread between people. He considered things like slogans, fashion trends, music, and dances and compares them to the way biological genes spread throughout people. The word itself originates from the Greek term mimeme meaning “imitated thing.”

(Richard Dawkins meme via Reddit)
    In her essay “On Words: What Does Meme Mean?,” UVA’s director of creative writing and poetry writing, Lisa Russ Spaar, suggests that the first memes were cave paintings by ancient civilizations. Spaar draws a parallel between these widespread carved images and modern day memes online. Images that that resonate widely such as animals, food, and other people were shared on the walls of ancient caves and still are on our iPhone screens.
 

First Real Memes

    With the rise of the internet in the 1990’s and early 2000’s, memes as we know them began to take form. An image, text, or combination, would be posted to a community online. That community would then take the object, remix it, and spread it. In a paper written by several collaborators titled “On the Origins of Memes by Means of Fringe Web Communities,” the earliest instances of memes are cited to be "Trollface," "Bad Luck Brian," and "Rickroll.” These simple images (and one video) were relatable and easily reposted and remixed. Their simplicity and remix-ability embodies the essence of the memes we enjoy today.



    While many early memes have an "unknown" origin, the most common platform identified in the study was YouTube. Regardless, each of these platforms contributed to the overall development of memes in integral ways. The following table displays data from "The Origins of Memes..." in order to illustrate the sources of original memes.

Where did classic memes originate from?

Platform

Percentage of memes

Reddit

7%

Tumblr

8%

Twitter

11%

4chan

12%

YouTube

21%

Unknown

28%

Technology Changes

Between then and now, many technological advancements have contributed to the sheer volume of memes that now exist on the internet. After its release to the public in 1993, the internet grew over decades into the most impactful and widely-used vessel for ideas and information. The fast-paced nature of our current digital landscape didn’t appear overnight, but as the internet grew, memes grew with it.
    The more platforms that were released and rose to popularity, the more opportunity there was for variation in meme generation. New communities formed and their connectedness lended itself to meme creation. Different platforms influence how memes are created, whether it be through community or cross-platform reposting. For example, viral meme videos on YouTube are often screenshotted and used as static memes on other platforms such as X and Instagram. 
(screenshot of Twitter showing a screenshot of a TikTok video)

Present day state of memes

Memes have evolved from simple jokes on the internet into cultural phenomenon that often enter mainstream culture. They transcend video or photo formats and often are layered upon one another. Memes exist in a complex web where the context in which they were created is of the utmost importance. Some memes carry negative connotations based on who made them and why. For example, memes have become a significant part of the political landscape, being used as propaganda by world leaders in order to sway younger populations.
    These days, creating a meme isn’t easy, and it is often out of any creator’s hands. Memes are unique in that it is up to the online community if it will catch on and actually become one. There is a difference between what is referred to as a “shit post” and a bona fide meme. An element of meme creation that is hard to pin down is the natural selection that takes place: A special few posts that gain traction in a community can become a meme and continue to morph into the public consciousness, while others will fade into obscurity. A survival of the fittest if you will.

(Image depicting natural selection in giraffes)

    The way memes form is oddly biological. As Dawkins described, memes cross and mix like genetic traits. The mixes produce new variants that can branch into sub-memes, incorporating imagery from a mix of source memes. This spontaneous process is truly chaotic and unpredictable. 

How Memes Build Community

    Memes can bring people together, for better or worse. Their significance to specific subcultures encourages group mentality, where reposting memes that are inside jokes can signal to others that you are a part of an in-group. Sometimes though, memes can spread across subcultures and eventually bring the larger population together. 
    Just look at six-seven. 

(From article about 67 being the word of the year)

    Why was this such a phenomenon? Why are college students and first graders making this hand gesture and giggling alike? 
    Six seven embodies the potential of memes to transcend geographic or societal barriers. The meme, originating from a rap song and being popularized by “the 67 kid,” takes little brain power to understand and is widely recognizable. The origins of the meme are somewhat unknown, proving that a word or hand movement can be meme-d so hard that it loses all meaning. Its wide spread use has led to countless “wholesome” interactions, being posted online and adding to its popularity.
Sometimes, though, memes can unify people under harmful ideologies in anti-social corners of the internet. Fringe communities such as 4chan often use memes to reinforce harmful stereotypes, perpetuating racism, misogyny, homophobia, ableism… really, anything you can think of, there is a community meme-ing it inappropriately on 4chan.

4chan

This platform is a primary producer for memes, being the birthplace or causing the popularization of many well-known memes. The sheer volume of meme material being produced on this website leads to a strong influence on larger meme trends. 
    4chan posts are anonymous and often lost to the traffic of the website, so users feel emboldened to try new things and make outlandish/hateful posts for fun. The combination of these factors, plus the website’s lax moderation, has led to high volumes of hate speech going generally unchecked. For example, “Pepe Frog,” the 2016 Tumblr darling, was popularized by 4chan and users on alt-right subsets of the website delighted in creating harmful imagery using the frog. 4chan’s common use of memes to spread hateful rhetoric points to the harmful potential of memes.

(From article interviewing Pepe Frog's original creator)

Weaponized Memes

The concept of weaponized memes is also described by the collaborators on “On the Origins of Memes by Means of Fringe Web Communities”. These memes can come in many forms and from many sources, but they are important to be aware of in any form. Posted by political parties, influencers, or even average internet users, memes can be used to sway and manipulate public opinion. As alluded to, memes can be used by fring internet communities to spread their ideology across the internet. Examples of this are simple and often unrecognizable to the unprepared, which makes it easier to absorb their ideology.
    An example of a dog whistle meme is egg dumplings. Imagine: you are an Austrian internet user that is scrolling through Instagram on April 20th. A post from an old friend of yours appears on your feed. It’s a random photo of egg dumplings with no context. You might just scroll by without a second though due to its absurdist and seemingly nonsensical nature. Unfortunately, in this scenario, your old friend is a Nazi. In Austria, a common nazi dog whistle is to post “Hitler’s favorite meal”, egg dumplings, on his birthday, April 20th. On the internet, what may seem like silly meme-ing upon first sight could be a much darker dog whistle.  
    However, some weaponized memes are much more recognizable. Recently, Donald Trump has employed popular memes among Gen Z and Alpha in order to attract younger supporters. For example, on March 6, Trump posted an edit of real military footage edited to fit a common meme format; the "wasted' screen that shows when you die in Grand Theft Auto V. The trend of memes being co-opted by the president is a concerning example of modern day propaganda. 

(Screenshot of post from the official White House account)

Digital Blackface

Another harmful form of meme-ing that internet users perpetuate is what is known as digital blackface. In an article for UC Berkley, Tor Haugan describes this phenomenon as a parallel to minstrelsy from the 19th and 20th centuries. It involves internet users co-opting Black language and imagery for internet communication. Common forms of digital blackface include reaction gifs, AAVE phrases, and Black profile pictures or avatars on the profiles of non-Black users.

By using these snapshots of Black culture, users often inadvertently perpetuate stereotypes. They display limited depictions of Black people, flattening their humanity and creating a one-dimensional caricature. Haugan also argues that digital blackface appropriates Black culture for entertainment, using their faces, humor, and phrases without acknowledging the systemic issues Black people face. In fact, some memes rely on Black people’s suffering for their humor: Take a look at “Ain’t Nobody Got Time for That” and “Bed Intruder.”
(above: Ain't Nobody Got Time for That remix, below: Bed Intruder Song)

    These videos have 25 million and 150 million views respectively. Early-internet memes like these embody the problem with digital blackface. Both of these individuals were expressing pain and discomfort on professional news interviews, then got meme-d and laughed at by the internet. Haugan also urges against the rampant normalization of digital Blackface. Because these images are constantly being remixed and reposted, they are not seen as wrong or out of place and instead allowed to thrive.

Conclusion

    Evidently, there are complex layers to meme creation and dissemination. It is always important to consider a meme’s cultural context and question its ideological messaging. In this post, I started to describe the dangers of memes in the wrong hands. Despite their silly nature, memes can perpetuate stereotypes and hate speech, both pursposely and unknowingly. Taking everything into account, moving forward, our definition of a “meme” will be as follows:

“An image, video, phrase, or body movement that communicates humor or absurdity and spreads virally across the internet for entertainment purposes.”

    In my next post, I will look at instances of marketing fails using memes, analyzing why they failed and where they could have done better. For now, please let me know what you think about all this. Which meme is your favorite? Have you seen any other instances of harmful memes recently? Leave a comment below.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

I Just Wanna Be Part of Your Symphony: Effective Marketing Using Memes

       It seems like every brand is trying to seem relatable online. In a world where we see hundreds of ads, paid partnerships, and sponsored posts a day, what manages to break through the chaos and stick with us?      Today we’ll look at cases of brands who have used memes to break through the monotony: Zara Larsson, who used a meme to re-brand, and Taco Bell, whose social media strategy revolves around meme posting. Both of these brands have found success online because of meme content: Their usages were serendipitous and down-to-earth. While the brands were opportunistic, they were able to maintain relatability and trust. (Image via Zara Larsson's instagram ) Symphony and Zara Larsson In the Summer of 2024, an edit to Zara Larson ’s song Symphony started a wave of memes using the song. The format of the meme was to use a slideshow of dreamy, summery images of jumping dolphins to the song with text that was completely out of left field. Examples a...

Why Marketers Need to Think Twice About Their Meme Usage

     Who else sees brands or organizations apologizing for posts they made all the time? I feel like so many of these attention grabs are desperate and not fully thought out. Because of their haste, marketers often make huge mistakes when trying to engage with internet users at their level.     By analyzing two cases of brands whose use of memes resulted in negative outcomes, we will explore what causes meme marketing to fail. In my opinion, to effectively use memes, marketers need to be aware of their cultural context and take time to fully analyze their implications. We must ask what groups created the memes and what groups are affected by them. ( Image source ) Case 1:  Burger King on Women’s Day      It seems Burger King found out that women are underrepresented in the culinary industry in 2021. The marketing team, realizing it was International Women's Day, decided then was a great time to point out that they actually educated a lot of ...