Skip to main content

Academic Literature Review

    Every source used in my project, whether directly cited or used as inspiration, is listed here. In alphabetical order, each source has a brief description of its contents and how it was used in my blog posts. 


Allio, R. J. (2008, March). A conversation with Gary Hamel: It's time to reinvent management. Strategy and Leadership 36(2):5-10. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235301753_A_conversation_with_Gary_Hamel_It's_time_to_reinvent_management 

This source, while removed from my core topic of meme marketing, is an interesting perspective to include in my project. Hamel, a management consultant, has been writing and speaking about the outdated processes in business management for close to 20 years. In this interview from 12 years ago, Hamel explains that technological advancement has always yielded a reimagined workplace, but the rise of the internet has not changed bureaucratic systems in business. While convoluted systems of approval originally allowed businesses to function at large scales, they now undermine initiative in a fast-paced economy. The author urges against hierarchical layers that isolate executives and disempower lower level employees. This applies to my project because I used it as proof of how hard it can be for businesses to use memes due to their long approval processes. These bureaucratic stalls can be detrimental to the fast-paced nature of meme marketing.


Bardon, A. (2023, April 24). Meme Marketing: The Future of Social Media Marketing. Lindenwood University. https://www.lindenwood.edu/blog/meme-marketing-the-future-of-social-media-marketing/ 

This source is a guide for brands using memes in their social media marketing strategies. The potential benefits of meme marketing are listed as follows: Low cost, wide reach, high engagement, ease of use, and universal appeal. Bardon then describes the possible challenges as lack of longevity, high competition (many brands using memes these days), necessary research, and potential to offend. In my project, I compared these outlines challenges to how a meme usage was successful in order to illustrate their positive meme use.


Best, S., You, M., & Young, D. R. (2024). Meme Aesthetics. Representations, 168(1), 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1525/rep.2024.168.1.1 

This source is a chapter of Representations by Stephen Best, Mia You, and Damon Ross Young. The chapter describes memes as ever evolving cultural objects that exist through collective recognition and participation. The authors emphasize the importance of the Black community in meme creation, describing the common “black” image or voice in memes: “One cannot think memes without noticing something black about them; one cannot think blackness without noticing the meme-like way in which black images tend to circulate.” The authors position memes as products of “communicative capitalism,” degrading the environment, politics, and our attention spans. This cynical perspective on memes is a unique and important one, illustrating how careful brands need to be when using memes in marketing.


Blackburn, J. Caulfield, T. De Cristofaro, E. Sirivianos, M. Stringhini, G. Suarez-Tangil, G.  Zannettou, S. (2019 November). On the Origins of Memes by Means of Fringe Web Communities. ACM Digital Library. https://seclab.bu.edu/people/gianluca/papers/memes-IMC2018.pdf

This text is a research paper conducted by several scholars from universities in the United States and London. It finds data about specific individuals who are influential in meme communities and which communities are likely to share racist or hateful content. The text provides graphs, tables, and formulas to classify and analyze activity on popular websites for meme distribution. The text introduces the concept of “weaponized” memes, when a meme is fueled by political ideology and propaganda, calling to attention the rampant racism and hate speech promoted by some influential communities in meme creation. The paper states, “Internet memes are increasingly used to sway and manipulate public opinion.” While most meme-users are well-meaning and unaware, many of the commonly spread memes online have hateful subtext. 


Cohen, K. (2024). This Is Fine. Representations, 168(1), 48–54. https://doi.org/10.1525/rep.2024.168.3.48 

Kris Cohen examines the “This is fine” meme, revealing a deeper meaning to the seemingly simple internet trend. Cohen claims the meme actually represents a sense of social resignation or even crisis. Through his analysis, he claims that most if not all memes represent complex, sometimes dark, collective emotions. This complicates using memes in marketing, as a brand can not easily understand or utilize the significance of certain memes. Cohen describes memes as static, representing a specific feeling and moment in time. He urges marketers to be careful trying to move memes out of their context or to “fix” them for their purposes. 


George, B. (2022). Why Meme Marketing is not the future: “There might never be Morbin Time.” Northeastern.edu. https://cpscomm.sites.northeastern.edu/2022/07/08/public-relations-and-the-dangers-of-meme-marketing-why-it-will-never-be-morbin-time/ 

Benjamin George has issues with the idea of memes in marketing. George critiques the idea that virality online automatically translates into an increased return on investment. The author uses the movie Morbius’s theatrical re-release to illustrate his point. “Morbin Time” was a trending meme, however the movie’s re-release saw poor attendance and was an overall failure. George asserts that online engagement with the “Morbin Time” trend was ironic rather than sincere, leading to an unsuccessful re-release. He also warns marketers that while meme marketing can seem easy and simple, you risk being the joke, and if it gets out of a brand’s control it can lead to financial and reputational risks.


Haugan, T. (2020, October). Blackface has resurged in the internet age. And you might be part of the problem. UC Berkeley Library https://www.lib.berkeley.edu/about/news/digital-blackface 

This source introduces the idea of “digital blackface,” an ancestor of minstrelsy in the United States. The minstrel portrayal of Black people was dehumanizing and stereotypical, and the article compares it to how Black images are used in memes today. The article describes that digital blackface can be easily and quickly shared, and remixed in massive volumes.  “Like advertising or propaganda … digital blackface subtly normalizes these caricatured depictions through its sheer ubiquity.” This article was important in my project because it clearly lays out the issues with digital blackface in memes and how important it is to avoid using these sorts of images and ideas in meme marketing. 


Huddle, S. (2018, February). The Birth of a Meme - What is it Anyway? Old Dominion University. https://www.odu.edu/article/the-birth-of-a-meme-what-it-anyway 

This source, an essay from Old Dominion University, describes the origin of memes and debates popular definitions of the word. Huddle then explains that there is no guaranteed way to create a meme because it needs to be a community effort. It needs to be reposted, remixed, and spread after its initial creator shares it. Lastly, the essay mentions corporate America’s use of memes in marketing, tying into my capstone’s overall topic. Huddle claims that while memes in marketing are appealing due to their low cost, “The drawback is there is no guarantee these efforts will result in a meme. The success rate of corporate brand attempts to create their own memes is incredibly low.” For my project, this source offers a perspective on how memes are created: not by a single author, but rather by a culmination of users and creators in a given online community. Also, the essay’s perspective that memes rarely work for advertisers will be useful for comparison with other arguments.


Manrai, A. Manrai, L. Murray, N. (2014). Memes, Memetics and Marketing: A State-of-the-Art Review and a Lifecycle Model of Meme Management in Advertising. Business Faculty Books and Book Chapters. https://digitalcommons.chapman.edu/business_books/4/

This is Chapter 18 of “The Routledge Companion to the Future of Marketing” written by Noel Murray, Ajay Manrai, and Lalita Manrai. This chapter connects the concept of memes to marketing and advertisement theory. The text describes memes as cultural replicators that propagate ideas through repetition and imitation. It describes successful brands as behaving like memes, spreading and replicating culturally. The text defines the life cycle of a meme in advertising and marketing contexts: transmission, decoding, infection, storage, survival, and finally retransmission. The authors also discuss the criteria that make a meme suitable for use in marketing. The list includes fecundity, simplicity, primordial drives, high-quality production, and vector fit. The author ultimately concludes that memes need an “empirically testable framework” in order to be useful in marketing research. This source is a scholarly look at how memes can be integrated into marketing efforts, citing specific cultural phenomena and behaviors, and explaining how they apply to meme marketing.


Molina, M. Erlichman, S. (2026). The role of Internet memes in creating a sense of belonging and community in an online setting. Bellisario College of Communications. https://bellisario.psu.edu/media-effects-research-lab/research/the-role-of-internet-memes-in-creating-a-sense-of-belonging-and-community-i 

This source is a study conducted by Maria Molina and Sara Erlichman at the Penn State College of Communications. The researchers hypothesized that “Users exposed to meme content will perceive a higher sense of community and (b) will perceive a higher sense of belonging, compared to those exposed to non-meme content.” They also hypothesized that users exposed to memes would find the content more humorous than those not exposed, as well as finding the internet more positive as a whole. Their results indicated their hypotheses were partially supported except for the one that claimed meme-exposed users would find them more humorous. This study illustrates the power that memes hold as a means of unification and collective understanding, assisting me in reaching conclusions about meme marketing.


Munson, K. (2021, February). The Dark Side of Memes. Utah State Magazine.

https://utahstatemagazine.usu.edu/scitech/the-dark-side-of-memes/ 

This source is a summary of a speech given at Utah State University by computer science professor Nick Flann. The talk was titled “Meme Menace: How Disinformation Spreads on Social Media.” Flann compares memes to a biological virus that infects a host's mind, replicating and spreading. The text describes the dangerous potential of memes to spread disinformation, especially in our technological landscape of advanced generative AI. This ecosystem is prone to conspiracy theories and harbor dangerous ideologies. The reader is urged to be careful about what they trust and share online. In my blog posts, this perspective will allow me to understand implications of memes in society such as propaganda and misinformation.


Ngo, T. M. (2021). Meme marketing: How viral marketing adapts to the internet. University of Northern Iowa Honors Program Theses. https://scholarworks.uni.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1484&context=hpt 

This source, written by Triet Minh Ngo, argues that meme marketing is inevitable for brands looking to reach virality on social media. The evolution of internet culture has made it so that using memes in online marketing is the most obvious and easy way to reach virality. Ngo describes how brands can speak the language of digital communities to increase engagement, which in this day and age entails using memes. She sees memes as a tool to increase organic reach by strategically imbedding one’s marketing message into them. This source also contains several datasets obtained through Ngo’s research, outlining where people find memes, where they share them, and how they engage with them.


Olmsted, C. How to Do Things with Memes. (2020, August). Colorado Boulder Department of Linguistics. https://www.colorado.edu/linguistics/2020/08/21/how-do-things-memes 

This source uses three concepts taken from “the field of computer-mediated discourse” to explain how memes work. The concepts are redistribution, recontextualization, and remediation. Redistribution is explained as the act of sharing a form of media with someone else, unchanged from its original state. This concept began before memes as we know them with chain emails. Next, recontextualization describes using an original quote or reference in different contexts, changing the meaning. Lastly, remediation is when memes are combined and mixed in a way that requires levels of context to understand. This is the final form of meme creation and the most impactful.  This source outlines the process of meme creation and the importance of understanding memes in marketing: to create the most impactful memes, they must be layered with context, but make sure that you are aware of all of the layers.


Peat, S. (2023, December). Literacy professor researches the “meme-ing” of life and education. (n.d.). UNM Newsroom. https://news.unm.edu/news/literacy-professor-researches-the-meme-ing-of-life-and-education 

This source describes a conversation with Professor Mary Rice about the value of memes in learning. She is quoted saying “You're trying to find things that are interesting to them and that draw on the strengths that they have … what are the strengths that they bring and what are the kinds of things that they're good at and that are interesting?” Rice describes the importance of meeting students where they are to turn learning into something exciting. This source was an interesting perspective for my project. Looking at Duolingo’s social media strategy as a learning tool, the company understands their audience and how to meet them at their level: with memes.


Pettis, B. (2021, October). KNOW YOUR MEME AND THE HOMOGENIZATION OF WEB HISTORY. University of Wisconsin-Madison

https://journals.uic.edu/ojs/index.php/spir/article/download/12009/10383 

This paper is about Know Your Meme (KYM), “a website devoted to compiling histories, definitions, and examples of internet memes.” The source says KYM is an invaluable resource for scholars, journalists, and yes, marketers, who are looking to understand internet memes. However, the paper problematizes the perspective of the website: while it provides surface level definitions and references, it can overlook entire uses of certain memes, especially ones associated with harmful ideologies. Pettis calls for users to avoid over-reliance on KYM as a source and instead seek out the specific communities that these memes originate from. If you do not do your research outside of KYM, you could misuse a meme in a way that causes harm. For my purposes, this source provided a perspective on the cultural context around memes and how important that is. It also helped me find alternative avenues for meme research besides KYM. 


Pond, K. Memes to an End: Investigating the Commodification of User-Generated Content. J413 Senior Research Capstone https://journalism.uoregon.edu/sites/default/files/2024-12/j413-pond-keegan-capstone-memetics-paper-64.pdf 

This article describes the way that brands co-opt memes and other user-generated content in order to appear friendly and “human.” It describes the way users online regarded brands like they were celebrities: “admired their cleverness, embraced their absurdity, and even wanted to get roasted for fun.” This phenomenon of brand humanization happens because people feel disconnected in an increasingly chaotic and AI-generated online feed. When a brand presents with memes and seems entertaining and relatable, it fosters a parasocial relationship between the brand and their audience. Brendan Kelly is quoted as saying, “If we’re looking to brands on Twitter as a way to connect with humanity, then we’re irrevocably fractured as a society. They don’t love you. I would like to repeat that: They don’t love you.”


Punia, K. Dr. Balgopal, S. (2025, December). Clicks, Cringe, or Conversion? Ethical and Emotional Reactions to Branded Memes. Journal of Content, Community & Communication, Amity School of Communication https://www.amity.edu/gurugram/jccc/pdf/JCCC_December_2025/Paper%20-%2003.pdf

In this source, authors Kuljeet Punia and Dr. Balgopal Singh discuss engagement versus conversion. They write that while branded memes are highly effective at capturing attention and evoking positive emotions, they have minimal power to drive direct sales or behavioral outcomes. Rather, memes serve as cultural signals: “effective for reach but insufficient for ROI unless integrated with broader strategies.” The authors suggest using a broader, more strategic lens when assessing a meme’s importance to your brand. For my project, this source provided a strong perspective on the downsides of meme marketing.


Smith, J. (2018, October). What’s the Meme-ing? Colorado State University #CSUSocial https://social.colostate.edu/trends/whats-the-meme-ing/ 

This article, written by Jan Smith from Colorado State University, explores memes in marketing and acts as a guide for brands looking to incorporate memes into their content. It uses several examples of popular meme images and formatting used by brands in the past, explaining how they were positive. It also describes the pitfalls of using memes in marketing. It urges companies to know their audience, that older demographics will not resonate with memes. It describes using memes in moderation and ensuring that brands also create original content alongside the meme content. Finally, the article stresses the importance of thoughtfulness: by misusing a meme, it can backfire and generate bad publicity. This source provided a reference for my research when looking for examples of meme marketing and another perspective on them.


Spaar, L. R. (2019, July). On Words: What Does ‘Meme’ Mean? UVA Today Archive  https://archive.news.virginia.edu/content/words-what-does-meme-mean/ 

This source outlines the origins of the word “meme” and provides a history of the word. From the perspective of an English professor, this source is a unique look at how memes came to be. A particularly interesting point is when Spaar suggests that the first memes were cave paintings by ancient civilizations. She draws a parallel between these widespread carved images and modern day memes online. Images that resonate widely such as animals, food, and other people were shared on the walls of ancient caves and still are on our iPhone screens.


Ward, M. R. (2025, February). Internet Meme Marketing over the Fad Cycle. American Marketing Association Journal of Interactive Marketing Volume 61, Issue 1

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/10949968251320612 

The author of this source uses a series of data points and formulas to create graphs that illustrate the lifecycle of memes from different sources. The paper explains that the popularity of a new “element of culture” is uncertain, and those that do succeed in pinpointing the peak will eventually see the meme die and turn to another “design, phrase, or meme.” Brands that want to use a popular meme will always run into this issue: will the meme still be popular by the time this campaign is approved? Oftentimes, the answer is no.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What's in a Meme?: Meme History, Highlights, and Hate Speech.

Everybody loves memes. Even those who claim indifference probably unknowingly quote a meme every once in a while. Memes can bring people together or tear them apart, and their power as cultural objects is an under-studied phenomenon. In my blog, I will explore memes in marketing and reach a conclusion on how best to approach them professionally. However, before exploring memes in the context of communications, we must explore both their history as well as their role in present day internet culture. ( Meme made by me depicting my current feelings) Origin of the Word "Meme"      In 1976, zoologist and science communicator Richard Dawkins  coined the word “meme” in his book “The Selfish Gene.” As Sarah Huddle describes in “The Birth of a Meme - What is it Anyway?,” Dawkins was interested in the way that cultural ideas replicate and spread between people. He considered things like slogans, fashion trends, music, and dances and compares them to the way biological genes...

I Just Wanna Be Part of Your Symphony: Effective Marketing Using Memes

       It seems like every brand is trying to seem relatable online. In a world where we see hundreds of ads, paid partnerships, and sponsored posts a day, what manages to break through the chaos and stick with us?      Today we’ll look at cases of brands who have used memes to break through the monotony: Zara Larsson, who used a meme to re-brand, and Taco Bell, whose social media strategy revolves around meme posting. Both of these brands have found success online because of meme content: Their usages were serendipitous and down-to-earth. While the brands were opportunistic, they were able to maintain relatability and trust. (Image via Zara Larsson's instagram ) Symphony and Zara Larsson In the Summer of 2024, an edit to Zara Larson ’s song Symphony started a wave of memes using the song. The format of the meme was to use a slideshow of dreamy, summery images of jumping dolphins to the song with text that was completely out of left field. Examples a...

Why Marketers Need to Think Twice About Their Meme Usage

     Who else sees brands or organizations apologizing for posts they made all the time? I feel like so many of these attention grabs are desperate and not fully thought out. Because of their haste, marketers often make huge mistakes when trying to engage with internet users at their level.     By analyzing two cases of brands whose use of memes resulted in negative outcomes, we will explore what causes meme marketing to fail. In my opinion, to effectively use memes, marketers need to be aware of their cultural context and take time to fully analyze their implications. We must ask what groups created the memes and what groups are affected by them. ( Image source ) Case 1:  Burger King on Women’s Day      It seems Burger King found out that women are underrepresented in the culinary industry in 2021. The marketing team, realizing it was International Women's Day, decided then was a great time to point out that they actually educated a lot of ...