We need to talk about cringe culture.
Any brand on the internet runs the risk of using a slightly aged meme and falling victim to corporate cringe. In my last post, I provided examples of brands whose attempts at meme marketing resulted in scandal. This time, I want to explore some more common issues with brands that venture into memes, such as being “cringe.” Looking at the “brat summer” trend and I Can't Believe It’s Not Butter’s “genius panini” marketing campaign, I will explore how virality and timing can affect marketers. Due to factors like meme over-saturation, out-of-touch corporate leaders, and the fast-paced cycle of a meme’s life, brands can have a hard time choosing which trend to utilize and when.
("life of a meme" comic by Alex Krokus)
Brat Summer: Meme cycles and over-saturation
What happened in the Summer of 2024 after Charli XCX released “brat” will make history books. The brat trend was so viral that Kamala Harris incorporated it into her presidential campaign. However, when a meme becomes as widespread as this one, it is only a matter of time until the internet’s interest runs out. Brands that overused the “brat” meme and the public’s reaction will show that when a meme becomes oversaturated, it starts to lose its energizing power.
("brat" album cover, origin of meme)
By mid July, it seemed like everywhere you looked there was brat green. It was in profile pictures, edits, even in fashion. The internet loved the album’s branding and co-opted it into a true viral meme. Along the way, brands began to realize that brat summer was a very cool thing that the kids were into. Of course, corporate America had to join in on the fun.
(collage of brat marketing)
It was fun for a while, but as early as August 1, TikTok users began discussing the over-saturation of the meme. User eugbrandstrat posted a video that complained about brands still hopping on the trend. He refers to pre-Kamala and post-Kamala for when the meme was officially dead– that estimation means it had a lifespan of only 45 days!
“If you’re a social media manager still thinking, our brand’s green, maybe we can do something cool like this- STOP. You’re too late.”
He says that brands have little to no time left until it’s embarrassing to use the meme, saying it has “peak corporate cringe” potential. The comments were in agreement. While “brat summer” had a built in end date of September, consumers were tired of seeing it from brands only halfway through the season.
(Comments on the video in question)
This case illustrates the very quick cycle of a meme and the lag in marketing teams: If you don’t move fast, you risk using a dead meme and falling victim to corporate cringe.
In “Internet Meme Marketing over the Fad Cycle” by Michael R. Ward, the author uses a series of data points and formulas to calculate a graph showing what you and I already know: a meme’s rise to popularity is just as swift as its fall.
The paper explains that the popularity of a new “element of culture” is uncertain, and those that do succeed in pinpointing the peak will eventually see the meme die and turn to another “design, phrase, or meme.” Brands that want to use a popular meme will always run into this issue: will the meme still be popular by the time this campaign is approved? Oftentimes, the answer is no.
In an interview from 12 (twelve!!) years ago, a professor named Gary Hammel called for a new system of decision making. He writes that technological advancement has always yielded a reimagined workplace, but the rise of the internet has not changed bureaucratic systems in business. While convoluted systems of approval originally allowed businesses to function at large scales, they now undermine initiative in a fast-paced economy. The author urges against hierarchical layers that isolate executives and disempower lower level employees.
(meme about the inefficiency of bureaucracy)
I’d have to agree with Hammel. In 2014 and especially now in 2026, any large corporation that relies on long-winded bureaucratic processes of approval for marketing would completely miss out on a huge trend like brat summer. And, if they do utilize the meme, it will be too late, creating more corporate cringe for reddit to snark about.
Short lived memes like brat summer are risky for brands: The oversaturation within such a short time period led to preemptive consumer burnout. So, what can a large brand do with memes? Is there a way to use a dead meme in an effective way?
This next brand certainly tried.
Genius Panini: Dead meme resurrected?
I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter is an old, established brand with a solid consumer base. They recently launched a campaign that is a clear grab for reach and engagement with a younger audience… with Gordon Ramsay as the face.
Gordon Ramsay has long been an icon of the internet with an array of memes coming out of the 25+ different shows throughout his career. However, none have been as widely recognized as the once viral “idiot sandwich” meme.
(Idiot sandwich original meme)
Ramsay is widely known as a very strict and serious guy, a persona he upholds on his shows. This meme stems from a sketch that Ramsay did making fun of his gruff and often outright mean persona on The Late Late Show with James Corden.
The meme gained traction and overtime and became widely used on tumblr and other socials, but of course, 12 years later, the meme is officially dead. So, how did I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter revamp it so long after its peak?
The campaign involves Ramsay being extremely surprised at the taste of what he can’t believe isn’t butter. He grabs the brand representative with slices of bread and tells her she’s a “genius panini,” before walking off swearing about how good the not-butter is. It is a humorous and interesting reinterpretation of the meme.
It’s clear that this meme calls back to millennials and older Gen-Z more than Gen Alpha. As a Gen-Zer, I can say that this meme reminds me of simpler times in my life and on the internet, which I’m sure is why it was used by the brand. We’ve come to a time on the internet where old internet memes are nostalgic to those of us who grew up online. Utilizing these feelings is a pretty smart idea from the marketing team, and the execution was a little cringe but could have been much worse. However, the public opinion was split.
(AI engagement summary)
Gemini was able to generate a user sentiment table based on comments from the brand’s socials as well as comments from pages that don’t belong to them. As shown above, positive opinions on the campaign involve its clever use of the meme and its entertainment value. However, negative comments are more skeptical of the brand and of Ramsey seeing the deal as a sell-out. Many of the negative comments were actually from older (50+) users that found the excess swearing inappropriate.
(Screenshot from the ad)
This case isn’t cut-and-dry. I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter tried to switch the context of an old, arguably dead meme using Ramsey as a spokesperson: It is a plan that has highlights and faults. A brand using a very old meme in an attempt to seem relatable can alienate younger consumers, although in this case the brand wanted to market to Gen-Zers and millennials, those who are buying their own groceries. However, targeting this demographic with “idiot sandwich” and Gordon Ramsey swearing also succeeded in alienating older, more conservative consumers.
Jen Smith from Colorado State illustrates my point best. In her piece What’s the Meme-ing? She writes that brands considering using memes in marketing need to know their audience. Because memes are born through online discussion forums that are frequented by younger audiences, you need to make sure your core audience will resonate.
Comments
Post a Comment